LurkbellAdd to Chrome

Blog

GummySearch Shuts Down on December 1, 2026: The Best Alternatives for Finding Customers on Reddit

Published

GummySearch is going away for good. It stopped taking new customers on November 30, 2025. On December 1, 2026, it shuts down for everyone who still pays, and the data gets deleted. That’s a lot of people losing a tool they used every week: the founder says more than 135,000 founders, marketers and investors signed up over the years.

If you’re one of them, you’ve got a few weeks left. We went through the options so you don’t have to. Fair warning: we make one of them (Lurkbell). We’ll tell you where it’s the right pick and where it isn’t.

Why it closed

The short story is Reddit. In his goodbye post, the founder explains that GummySearch ran on Reddit’s API, and they “were not able to reach an agreement that aligns with Reddit’s Data API Usage policies.”

It wasn’t a one-off, either. On October 1, 2026, Reddit announced it’s closing its public API in stages, finishing in March 2027, and switching off RSS feeds on November 13 (Decrypt has the details). Any tool that pulls Reddit data from its own servers now has the same problem GummySearch had. Ask how they get their data before you pay for a year.

What does a replacement cost?

This is where the options really differ. Here’s what each one costs over a year, using the prices on their websites in October 2026:

Tool AI filtering? Price Per year
Lurkbell Yes, you describe your ideal post in plain English Free plan; Pro $29 for a year $29
Sublookout No $12/month $144
KWatch.io Sentiment only Free tier, then from $19/month $228+
RedShip Yes, 0–100 lead score $29/month, or $199 paid yearly $199+
Subreddit Signals Yes, intent scores $29–59/month, less paid yearly $288–590
Syften Yes, from the $49.95/month plan $29.95/month without AI; $49.95 with AI $359, or $599 with AI
F5Bot Only on the Gold plan Free, or $49.99/month with AI $0 or $600

Look at the tools that use AI to pick out real leads, since that’s what most people used GummySearch for. Lurkbell is $29 for the whole year. Everything else in that group starts around $200 a year and goes up to $600. So you’d be paying 7 to 20 times more to do the same basic job: find out when someone on Reddit asks for what you sell.

Lurkbell (ours)

We built Lurkbell, and we use it to find customers for our other product. We kept the price low on purpose: it shouldn’t be another $50-a-month bill.

It’s a Chrome and Edge extension. You choose the subreddits where your customers hang out, then tell it what you’re looking for. That can be keywords, or a sentence like “a small business owner looking for a CRM, not someone selling one.” When a new post matches, you get a desktop notification, or a message in Discord, Telegram or Slack, along with a short note on why the AI thought it was a fit.

Pro is $29 for a year. It isn’t $29 a month, and it doesn’t renew on its own. The AI filter runs on your own Claude or OpenAI key, so you pay the AI company directly, at cost, rather than paying us a markup on it. There’s a free plan and a 7-day trial if you want to kick the tires first.

Because it reads Reddit through your own logged-in browser, it isn’t waiting on a licensing deal with Reddit, which is exactly what killed GummySearch.

What it won’t do: run while your browser is closed, watch anything other than Reddit, or give you GummySearch’s audience research dashboards. If those matter to you, read on.

F5Bot

F5Bot has been around for years and the free plan still works fine. It emails you when a keyword shows up anywhere on Reddit, Hacker News or Lobsters. For tracking your brand name or a competitor, it’s hard to beat free.

The catch is noise. It searches all of Reddit, so a phrase like “looking for a CRM” will fill your inbox with stuff you don’t care about. AI filtering exists, but only on the Gold plan at $49.99 a month.

Syften

Syften is the fast one. It checks Reddit and plenty of other communities, usually within a minute, and has an AI filter to cut junk. It’s a solid product if speed matters a lot to you or you need more than Reddit. The entry plan is $29.95 a month, but that one only sends email and RSS. The AI filter and Slack alerts start with the $49.95 Standard plan, so about $600 a year. You also write filters in a query syntax, which takes some getting used to. We compared it with cheaper options in Syften alternatives.

RedShip and Subreddit Signals

These two are the closest to GummySearch’s lead-finding side. RedShip and Subreddit Signals both score posts by how likely the author is to buy, and give you a ranked list to work through. RedShip will even draft a reply for you.

They’re polished, and they run without your browser being open. You’ll pay $29 to $59 a month for that, or $199 to $590 a year if you pay up front. They also pull from Reddit server-side, so it’s worth asking them what happens after Reddit’s 2027 cutoffs.

Sublookout and KWatch.io

If you just want a heads-up when a word appears, Sublookout ($12 a month, checks every 10 minutes) and KWatch.io (free tier, paid from $19) will do it by email or Slack. Neither tries to judge whether a post is a lead.

So which one?

If you used GummySearch to find people asking for products like yours, you want AI filtering. In our experience, keywords alone catch too much junk to be useful. For most solo founders and small teams, Lurkbell does that job for $29 a year, and nothing else comes close on price. Pick RedShip or Subreddit Signals if you’d rather have a hosted dashboard and the budget for a monthly plan doesn’t bother you.

If you only track your brand name, start with F5Bot’s free plan and see if it’s enough.

If you mostly used GummySearch’s audience research, nothing here fully replaces it. Honestly, reading a subreddit’s top posts from the past year, and searching inside it for “any recommendations” or “what do you use for,” gets you most of the way.

Before December 1

Export whatever you can from GummySearch while it’s still up: your saved audiences, the subreddits in them, and the searches that worked. For each audience, jot down three to five subreddits and the phrases your customers actually use (“looking for,” “alternative to,” “anyone recommend”). Those become your watches in whatever you move to.

Then run the new tool next to GummySearch for a week and see what each one catches.

You can try Lurkbell for free. If it works for you, a full year of Pro costs $29, less than a single month of most of the other options above.